Thursday, July 25, 2013

About validity, controversy and recognition of distance learning degree of PTU (Punjab Technical University) and KSOU (Karnataka State Open University)

Hello Friends, HR folks and all those who are inspiring me everyday to post about universities, degrees and other information on my blog,

Thanks a lot for your enormous love, question and motivation.
I have exposed SCDL, ICFAI, Welingkar(Distance), NMIMS (Distance), Jodhpur National, Shobhit, Vinayak Mission, MGU Shillong, Calicut, CMJ University, EIILM, SMU and many others. You will find all the information with proper evidence.
To clarify again, My whole intention is to improve quality of the education, bringing facts to you and make you aware. Any degree does not help in the career growth but a right degree and from a right university definitely do that.

I have a complaint with my readers. Few people ask same question again and again and the fact is, all the questions they have asked are already available on my this blog as well as http://simplygovind.blogspot.com I request you to please scan my blog first and if you are not satisfied with the information provided there, then put the question forward. Many time, I am busy at my work and other task so I cannot reply immediately. Please have patience and keep pouring your all queries.

Till now, I have exposed mostly the private university's unholy degree scams and now many actions happening from government side. But there are also  few state government universities who are violating various norms and offering degrees. The difference is: private universities are openly selling degrees whereas these state universities are violating norms, allowing malpractices and offering degrees through the franchisees. The result of this is hampering student's life. The degree obtained become non acceptable for higher studies and public sector job. Therefore students need to be very careful. Please do not go for easy degree which makes your life miserable. Better, do a little hard work. In the life, in the path of success, there is no short cut.


About acceptance of Punjab Technical University and Karnataka State Open University (KSOU)? Is the degree valid?
Well, Punjab Technical University's all full time degrees are valid. But its distance learning programme stands invalid.

What wrong have PTU and KSO done? It is a university so it can offer any degree.
No, this is the half truth that PTU can offer any degree.
To maintain the standard and quality of education including distance education, UGC issued circular and certain norms. After that DEC also set the same norms. Now DEC has dissolved and UGC as well as individual bodies are separately issuing approval related to distance education. Please read the following blog post for more details:

As per the circular as well as previous guidelines, following conditions apply to all universities and institutes offering distance learning programmes:
1. Universities must follow the territorial jurisdiction: This means a central university can offer distance learning degree anywhere in India. A state University can offer within their jurisdiction i.e. the district where they have jurisdiction. You may refer my various blogpost on the same. A private university cannot offer a distance learning course outside the city where they are situated and same rule applies to deemed universities.
Here, KSOU as well as PTU offered the courses in India and abroad breaching the guideline. Any degree in distance mode obtained by violating the jurisdiction becomes invalid for higher studies and public sector job.



2. Franchisee of higher education is not allowed: As per this guideline, all universities have to offer the degree courses by their own. They have to admit students, they have to conduct exams and they have to control everything. Any universities cannot offer franchisee of study centre, cannot allow a private individual to take franchisee and control role of the university. In case of PTU, KSOU as well as SMU, it has happened that they charged private individual and gave them franchisee of its courses. This is a violation and it lead to poor quality and lack of control in degree awarding. For example, IGNOU also offer courses in India and abroad but IGNOU has its own paid staff at regional centres, it controls examinations and overall operations. All universities must follow this norm. Few of the universities complying with this norms are : University of Mumbai, all other state government universities in Maharashtra, Patna University, Aligarh Muslim University, Maulana Azaad National University, University of Delhi, Kurukshetra University, Guru Nanak Dev University Amritsar, Universities in Gujarat etc. 

Due to the violation, degrees of KSOU, PTU and SMU becomes invalid.


3. Prior approval of other regulating body: Before offering courses in distance mode, it is mandatory to take approval of other controlling and regulating  bodies. Unfortunately, PTU, SMU as well as KSOU did not take any such approvals. I am listing course and approving body here for your understanding.

Sr. No.
Course Sectors
Degrees Nomenclature
Approving and controlling bodies
1
Engineering, IT and Management
Diploma in Engineering, BE, B.Tech, M.E., M.Tech, MBA, MMS, MBS, MBE, MCA, MCM, M.Sc. (Computer Science), MS (engineering, software, telecom( etc.,  Master of Management, PGDBA, PGDHRM, PGDMM, PGDFM, PGDM, M.Phil and Ph.D in engineering, technology, management
AICTE (All India Council for Technical Education), New Delhi
2
Architecture
Diploma in Architecture, B.Arch., M.Arch, M.Phil and Ph.D in architecture
Council of Architecture, New Delhi
3
Pharmacy
Diploma in Pharmacy (D. Pharm), Bachelor of Pharmacy (B. Pharm), Master of Pharmacy (M.Pharm), M. Phil and Ph.D in pharmaceutical science
Pharmacy Council of India (PCI), New Delhi
4
Nursing
ANM, GNM, Diploma in Nursing, B.Sc. Nursing, M.Sc. Nursing, M. Phil and Ph.D in nursing
Indian Nursing Council (INC), New Delhi
5
Medicine
MBBS, MD, DM, M.Ch., M.S., M.Sc. (field related to medicine only), Diploma, MHA, DPB, FCPS, MCPS, M.Phil and Ph.D in medicine and any course related to modern medicine
Medical Council of India (MCI), New Delhi
6
Law
LLB, LLM, M.Phil and Ph.D in Law
Bar Council of India, New Delhi
7
Ayurvedic Medicine
DAMS, BAMS, MD (Ayurvedic Medicine), MS (Ayurvedic Medicine), Diploma in Ayurved and Ph.D in Ayurvedic Medicine
Central Council of Indian Medicine (CCIM), New Delhi
8
Unani Medicine

Central Council of Indian Medicine (CCIM), New Delhi
9
Siddha and Naturopathy
Diploma in Naturopathy (ND), Bachelor of Naturopathy and Yogic Science (BNYS), Bachelor of Naturopathy (B.Nat.)
Department of AYUSH, Government of India
10
Homeopathy  
DHMS, BHMS, MD (Homeopathy), MS (Homeopathy), Ph.D Homeopathy
Central Council of Homeopathy, New Delhi
11
Teaching and teachers education
D.Ed, B.Ed., M.Ed., M.Phil and Ph.D in education
National Council for Teachers Education (NCTE), Bhopal
12
Rehabilitation and special education
D.Ed. Special Education, B.Ed. (Special Education), M.Ed. (Special Education), Post Graduate Diploma in Rehabilitation Psychology, Hearing impaired, learning disability etc., M.Phil and Ph.D in special Education
Rehabilitation Council of India, (RCI), New Delhi
13
Aerospace and Aircraft related courses
B.E./ B.Tech. (Aerospace), B.E./ B.Tech. (Aeronautical), Aircraft maintenance engineering, flying related course
AICTE and DGCA (Directorate General of Civil Aviation


So even if a university is approved from UGC, it is not sufficient. It has to take approval for the specialised courses above. As of now, except IGNOU nobody offer and nobody can offer B.Sc, Nursing. There is complete ban on offering engineering, pharmacy, architecture, medicine, ayurveda, unani, siddha, homeopathy and aerospace as well as aeronautical engineering courses through distance mode. KSOU, PTU and many other universities openly violated the norms and offered engineering courses through distance mode. Since prior approval was not taken, all these degrees stands invalid.


I hope this information is sufficient to understand why the degrees from SMU, KSOU and PTU is invalid. There are many other universities who are violating the norms. Since many students have trapped in these universities, I focussed the article on this. 



You may refer various newspaper link, show cause notice as follows for more evidence and information. 


Degree scam of Punjab Technical University


PTU barred from admitting students


Delhi HC order to stop admission to PTU

FIR against Punjab Technical University

KSOU defies DEC order

Higher education minister ask KSOU not to declare result

Karnataka Government warn stern action against KSOU


They are simply university. Why they are selling degrees rather than imparting education? I advise students not to take any admission in these universities.

Interested for our works and services?
Get more of our update !